Josh Reviews Norm: The Legend of Norm Macdonald
Judd Apatow has become a master at directing documentaries spotlighting brilliant comedians! The Zen Diaries of Garry Shandling, George Carlin’s American Dream, and Mel Brooks: the 99 Year Old Man! are all essential viewing for comedy fans, and now he’s back with Norm: The Legend of Norm Macdonald (as well as another documentary, Paralyzed by Hope: The Maria Bamford Story, that also dropped this month)!
Norm: The Legend of Norm Macdonald is a beautiful and well-deserved spotlight on the brilliant and very weird Norm Macdonald. I’ve been a huge fan of Norm’s for as long as I can remember, and like the rest of the world, I was shocked and so sad to hear that he had passed away in 2021 at only 61 years old. Norm had leukemia, something he had kept secret from almost everyone. It was a tremendous loss. (Not too long after Norm passed away, Netflix released a recording that Norm had made on his computer at home of a practice performance of what would have been his next stand-up special. It’s called Norm Macdonald: Nothing Special, and it’s phenomenal; a wonderful gift to Norm’s fans that only underlined how much comedic gas Norm still had in his tank.)
I love how immediately this documentary gets to the heart of Norm’s idiosyncratic brand of comedy. “Show business never really found a place to put him,” we hear Larry King say about Norm at one point, and it’s true! The doc traces Norm’s unusual career, which contained so many turns and twists. (I knew almost nothing, for example, about the video podcast Norm Macdonald Live that Norm made with sidekick Adam Eget, which was on YouTube from 2013-2016! I loved all the clips from that show we get to see in the doc.)
Of course, what Norm is most known for is his stint on SNL. Or, more precisely, what Norm is most known for is getting fired from SNL, after NBC’s head honcho Don Ohlmeyer insisted that Norm stop making jokes about Ohlmeyer’s buddy O.J. Simpson on Weekend Update, and Norm refused. The doc spends a good chunk of time exploring that situation and the fallout. I was very interested in that section; though actually what I wound up most interested in was the moment of reflection we got from Norm at one point, in which he expresses ambivalence about being so strongly associated by the general public with SNL, which he was only on for a few years. It was interesting to get that moment of what felt like real feeling from the hard-to-know Norm.
The doc spends a lot of time trying to capture the playful, enigmatic way Norm would present himself in public throughout his career. Ok, should I just say he lied? There are some very funny montages in which we see, for example, Norm giving his age inaccurately, claiming he never went to college (when photos and news articles of the time confirm he did), asserting at various time he was Polish or Scottish or of some other ancestry, and all sorts of other statements whose veracity is questioned by the doc. These sequences in the film are funny, but also seem key to getting some sort of understanding of Norm himself (an understanding which even this documentary about Norm seems to freely admit will always remain somewhat out of reach). The man wrote a fiction-version of a memoir, for goodness’ sake!! It’s interesting that the doc doesn’t manage to penetrate too deeply into Norm’s personal life. We see his mom briefly, towards the end of the doc, and his son, but we don’t even get a hint as to who his son’s mother is.
I enjoyed the approach that Mr. Apatow and his team took here, avoiding a cliche array of talking heads and instead assembling the doc from archival footage and photos. We often hear others speaking in voice-over; but — interestingly for a documentary project like this — there were NO newly-recorded interviews made for this doc. All the clips were taken from pre-existing footage. (Read more about this here, in the Hollywood Reporter’s interview with Judd Apatow & others.) There were a few times I wish I’d known more clearly who was talking and when the recording was from, but on the other hand, I liked the effect of being “in the moment” with the events we were watching, as opposed to always feeling we were watching a documentary film. I also liked the device Mr. Apatow & his team created with the transitions in the film; it’s like we’re watching an old VHS tape, being fast forwarded and rewound, or searching for clips on YouTube (which so many people did after Norm passed away). The effect worked nicely for me. In the film’s gloriously well-curated array of archival footage, it’s a joy to get to see and hear from so many comedic legends, including David Letterman, Conan O’Brien, Larry King (who is all over the doc!), Bob Saget, David Spade, Sarah Silverman, Jim Carrey, Molly Shannon, Adam Sandler, and so many more. (There’s a clip of Norm making a hilarious oral sex joke on Conan O’Brien’s show that nearly killed me, as well as the famous moment on Conan’s show in which Norm mercilessly poked fun at the new Carrot Top movie, Chairman of the Board.)
This is a feature-length documentary, clocking in at a hair over two hours. That’s a decently long doc, but it’s only about half the length of Mr. Apatow’s two-part documentaries on Garry Shandling, George Carlin, and Mel Brooks. On the one hand, this doc for sure left me wanting more. Norm created such a wealth of comedic highlights across his life and career, there are so many other moments it’d have been nice to have seen highlighted in the doc. On the other hand, two hours felt like the right length to me. I feel like we got a complete meal.
If you’re a comedy fan, don’t miss this. I had a blast watching Norm: The Legend of Norm Macdonald. I loved being reminded of so many great bits and jokes from across Mr. Macdonald’s career that I knew and loved, and being shown so many more gems that I’d never seen before. He was taken from us too soon. Watch Norm: The Legend of Norm Macdonald on Netflix now!
Thanks for reading! Please support my website by clicking through one of my Amazon links the next time you need to shop! As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. That means I’ll receive a small percentage from ANY product you purchase from Amazon within 24 hours after clicking through. Thank you!
And please sign up for my new Substack: Edelglass Half Full! This will be the main home for all of my blogs/reviews moving forward! Click below to sign up and get everything I write delivered directly to your email!
