Josh Reviews The Only Living Pickpocket in New York
In The Only Living Pickpocket in New York, John Turturro stars as Harry, who supports himself by lifting wallets, phones, watches, bracelets, and more off of the people he encounters in the city (mostly on the subway) and selling whatever of value he finds to his pal Ben (Steve Buscemi), who owns a small pawn shop. Harry is a talented thief, but he’s getting older, and the evolving world has started to leave him behind. (For instance, fewer people carry cash that he can swipe, and Harry doesn’t really understand how to use modern smart-phones.) Harry also has to support his wife Rosie, who for some time has been in a catatonic state, unable to move or speak. Still, Harry has made a life for himself. But that all gets turned upside down when Harry breaks into the car of the wrong guy; a rich young kid who turns out to be connected to a powerful mob family. Now Harry has only a few hours to find and return what he stole, or he and Rosie will pay the price…
This movie is a masterpiece. I absolutely loved every minute of it.
The film is a beautiful showcase for the great John Turturro. Ever since I was a kid, I have loved Mr. Turturro’s work; he’s been so great in so many movies: Do the Right Thing, Miller’s Crossing, Barton Fink, Quiz Show, The Big Lebowski, Cradle will Rock, Fading Gigolo, The Batman… and so many more. He’s also, of course, been spectacular recently in Severance. But this feels like the role Mr. Turturro was born to play. It’s one of those special, perfect blendings of character and actor. From minute one of this film, I fully believed that Mr. Turturro WAS Harry. I instantly loved and was rooting for this scruffy lowlife who has made the rough and tough streets and subways of New York City his own. Mr. Turturro seems to completely inhabit every nook and cranny of this guy. I was mesmerized just watching his face as we see Harry processing everything that he has to deal with over the course of this film. This is a towering performance that Mr. Turturro makes look so beguilingly effortless.
The Only Living Pickpocket in New York was written and directed by Noah Segan. I’ve enjoyed Mr. Segan’s work as an actor; he’s notable for appearing in pretty much everything directed by Rian Johnson, from Brick to Looper to Knives Out and more. I believe that this is only the second film that Mr. Segan has written and directed. (I’ve never seen his first film, a 2022 vampire story called Blood Relatives, but now I’m for sure going to have to track that down.) I can’t believe that this movie is Mr. Segan’s second film. The writing & directing are so competently & confidently done. The film has a self-assuredness and focus of vision that I hooked into immediately. I was impressed by how Mr. Segan was able to create such a rich and complex character as Harry. The film doesn’t shy away from showing us the damage and pain that Harry has caused by his choices, but it also shows great empathy for him and all that he’s been through. All of the supporting characters are beautifully drawn. Even characters who only appear for a scene or two feel like fully-realized characters, with lives of their own. Everything in the film’s story flows together beautifully from start to finish. I was extremely impressed with Mr. Segan’s work; I’ll be paying closer attention to him from here on out.
I was delighted by what a love letter this film is to New York City. The film explores the dangers and threats that exist in the city, from the mob to the people with sticky fingers like Harry. (There are some great sequences in the film in which we see passers-by from Harry’s point of view, where every purse and wallet and phone seems so easy to snatch. I found myself unconsciously feeling for my wallet while sitting in the theater, to make sure it was still there!) At the same time, the movie shows an affection for the city and its many low-life characters, the same affection Harry feels. It’s cool to see how completely comfortable Harry is when navigating New York. This type of quiet confidence is captivating. (I love, for instance, how quickly Harry is able to make short work of a padlock that I thought would be a huge obstacle for him.) One of my favorite scenes in the film is when Harry spots a young pickpocket and takes it upon himself to give this kid some tips on how to do this, and how to live this life. Not only is Harry completely unthreatened, he’s interested in trying to help this kid. There’s a special tradition of great New York movies — films like Ghostbusters, Manhattan, Annie Hall, When Harry Met Sally, Do the Right Thing, The Royal Tenenbaums, Goodfellas, Brooklyn, Uncut Gems, and so many more — and The Only Living Pickpocket in New York stands proudly among them.
As happy as watching John Turturro in this film made me, I was equally happy to see the great Steve Buscemi in a wonderful supporting role as Harry’s old pal and fence Ben. I love the easy friendship the film shows us these two old thieves have; how well they work together and how much they respect one another. Ben is sharp and competent, but it’s when things turn bad that Mr. Buscemi truly shines in the role. (There’s a terrific scene after Ben’s shop gets broken into, where we get some master-class acting from Mr. Buscemi.)
I became an immediate fan of Giancarlo Esposito’s in Breaking Bad (and of course I loved seeing him reprise his role as Gus Fring in Better Call Saul). He’s an amazing actor, but some of his recent high-profile work has felt to me like it hasn’t quite tapped his potential. (I’m thinking about his role on The Mandalorian, or in Megalopolis, or in Captain America: Brave New World.) So I was thrilled to see him inhabit such a juicy role here as Detective Warren. The film gives us just enough info on the backstory between Harry and Detective Warren to imagine how their long relationship might have played out. They probably started as adversaries, but over the years these two old men have settled into something approaching a friendship. I love the way Mr. Esposito plays this (beautifully well-written) role; he’s so different from Harry, and yet so alike. The moment, late in the film, in which Detective Warren insists that Harry have a cup of coffee, and gives him a wink, filled me with joy. (Watch this great movie and you’ll understand why!!) I thought it was one of the best moments I’ve seen in a movie all year.
Tatiana Maslany (She-Hulk: Attorney at Law) parachutes in for one pivotal scene, and she knocks it out of the park. It’s got to be so hard for an actor to join a project for just one scene, and have to deliver the emotional goods. This is a critical scene, and Ms. Maslany is phenomenal in it. Will Price does a fantastic job playing Dylan, the super-rich, super-spoiled child of a mob family who Harry makes the mistake of crossing. Victoria Morales is wonderful in a small role as Ben’s granddaughter Eve, who has all the knowledge about 2026 technology that Harry and Ben are missing. Karina Arroyave plays the catatonic Rosie, and she’s wonderful, a potent presence throughout the film, even though she cannot speak. John Gallagher Jr. (The Newsroom) has a small role at the start of the film; he’s perfect in the way he sets the stage for the film and allows us to understand what Harry does and to see the ripple effects left in his wake. Jamie Lee Curtis pops up at the end of the film in a role I won’t spoil, and she’s magnificent as always.
Watching this film, I kept wondering: was this going to be the type of film in which the plucky underdog hero outwits his enemies and has a happy ending? Or were we watching a tragedy that could only end badly? I of course wouldn’t dream of spoiling the ending, but I’ll say I was impressed at the way Mr. Segan wove his story beautifully between those two paths. The ending is rich in emotion, but it’s not so dour that I found the film punishing to watch the way some dramas can be. There’s also some light, but not in a way that felt unrealistic or that turned Harry into some kind of superhero.
I adored this movie. It’s a beautiful character study, and a wonderful showcase for John Turturro and this spectacular supporting cast.
Thanks for reading! Please support my website by clicking through one of my Amazon links the next time you need to shop! As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. That means I’ll receive a small percentage from ANY product you purchase from Amazon within 24 hours after clicking through. Thank you!
And please sign up for my new Substack: Edelglass Half Full! This will be the main home for all of my blogs/reviews moving forward! Click below to sign up and get everything I write delivered directly to your email!
